Skip to main content
The PBS on-demand streaming service, WNED PBS Passport, is now available in Canada! Learn More
About the Film

About the Film

Discovering New York Suffrage Stories

Women began their battle for the vote in Central and Western New York in the mid-1800s, most notably at the first women’s rights convention in Seneca Falls in July of 1848. The upstate region was an epicenter of reform, tackling societal issues of abolition, religion, and temperance. Activism around these issues laid the groundwork for women and men to take on women’s rights including the right to vote.

In New York, the suffrage movement’s success depended on thousands of women, but today, many of their stories are absent from history. Discovering New York Suffrage Stories shares the journeys of four women who tirelessly navigated issues of religious intolerance, sexism, and racism in the fight for suffrage.

Matilda Joslyn Gage worked alongside Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony, drawing from the inspiration of Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) women. Paulina Wright Davis used her experience in the anti-slavery movement to organize women’s rights conventions. She owned, edited, and published “The Una,” a periodical solely dedicated to the elevation of women. This revolutionary use of the media gave suffragists a platform to spread their message. Later in the movement, Hester Jeffrey from Rochester, New York led black women’s clubs and regularly crossed racial lines to work alongside white women for the vote. Mary Talbert, from Buffalo, NY elevated the issue of suffrage among Black women around the country, encouraging them to take on the issue of suffrage in their communities.

Sharing their journeys provides a more complete history of suffrage, which demanded the right to equal citizenship in America through the vote.

GOLD LINE

Who's Who in the Film

Susan Goddier

Susan Goodier, Ph.D.

Dr. Goodier studies U.S. women’s activism, particularly woman suffrage activism, from 1840 to 1920. In her classes at SUNY Oneonta and as a public scholar for Humanities NY, she shares the stories of Black and white women in suffrage activism. Dr. Goodier has authored many publications about suffrage, including the book Women Will Vote: Winning Suffrage in New York State. Visit our complete suffrage reading list to find out more.

“Look at what these suffragists did, with all their quirks and faults and failings. And yet they moved beyond those failings in order to make change in the world. That, to me, is the most important thing that we can do as human beings.”


SAlly Roesch Wagner

Sally Roesch Wagner, Ph.D.

Dr. Wagner has taught women’s studies courses for 50 years, focusing on interactions between ethnicity and gender and the influence of Native women on the suffrage movement. She continues to teach as an adjunct faculty member at Syracuse University. Dr. Wagner is also the founder and executive director of the Matilda Joslyn Gage Foundation. She has written extensively on Gage’s life and legacy, including the book Sisters in Spirit: Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) Influence on Early American Feminists. Visit our complete suffrage reading list to find out more.

“Why do I do the work I do? I do because I'm in love with a dead woman. I do it because I love Matilda Joslyn Gage. She was an insufferable woman. She was absolutely relentless. She would have, and does, push me to my better self all the time. And I do this work because I consider it an honor to carry on the work that she began.”


Lillian Williams

Lillian Williams, Ph.D.

Prof. Williams is Associate Professor and former chair of the Department of African American Studies at the University at Buffalo. Her work focuses on the intersection of race, ethnicity, gender, and social and political organizations. After decades of research, Prof. Williams is currently writing a biography of Mary Burnett Talbert.

“I figured if people understood the history that they would be receptive to change. So I teach African American history, women's history, because I want individuals to know the story and to use that knowledge to affect change.”


Laura Free, Ph.D.

As a historian of voting rights, Dr. Free is committed to openly confronting suffrage’s history of whitewashing and racism. Dr. Free is Associate Professor of History at Hobart & William Smith Colleges, a member of the NYS Women's Suffrage Commission, and host of the Amendedpodcast. You can find more about her book, Suffrage Reconstructed: Gender, Race, and Voting Rights in the Civil War Era, on our complete suffrage reading list.

“As we commemorate the 19th Amendment, I really appreciate that public historians are finally asking "Hey, there's so much more to this story than just the few people at the podium. Who else is involved?" It's so important to have a rich, diverse array of voices involved in figuring out what equality looks like and fighting for it.”


Judith Wellman, Ph.D.

Dr. Wellman shared her passion for New York State history, women's history, and 19th century U.S. history as Professor at SUNY Oswego. Today she is principal investigator for Historical New York Research Associates, focusing on social and community history, women's history, the Underground Railroad, and preserving local historic sites. Among her many publications is The Road to Seneca Falls: Elizabeth Cady Stanton and the First Woman's Rights Convention. You can find it and other great book suggestions on our complete suffrage reading list.

“I think it's important to remember our history because it's not gone. It's part of us. When I look in the mirror in the morning, I see a reflection of these women that have come before me, and I know they're part of me, but I'm also a part of them. ... One of the things we can do to honor their memory that would probably make them most happy, whether you're Mary Talbert or Susan B Anthony is, be sure to vote.”


Other Interviewees

Melissa Almeyda

A lifelong lover of history, Ms. Almeyda pursued her interest in the law and social change by obtaining her Juris Doctorate from The Catholic University of America, Columbus School of Law.

She continues to work for a world in which young girls and women have no societal limitations. Ms. Almeyda runs the day-to-day operations of the Matilda Joslyn Gage Foundation.


Mary Craig

An actress, historian, and advocate, Mary Craig performs throughout the Western New York region portraying Mary Burnett Talbert. When not sharing the story of this local icon, Ms. Craig has performed in numerous Artie-winning plays, written scripts for the stage and screen, and had an influential career in banking and non-profits. She is an invaluable member of the church and the local community.


Michael Galban

Michael Galban

Michael Galban (Mono Lake Paiute/Washoe) is the curator and historian for the Seneca Art & Culture Center at Ganondagan State Historic Site. Mr. Galban lectures and writes extensively on the colonial history of the east and Haudenosaunee material culture. For over 20 years, he has worked tirelessly with Haudenosaunee communities to preserve ancient arts.


Robin Nowell

Robin Nowell

Robin Nowell is the unofficial historian for the Rochester African Methodist Episcopal Church, where Hester Jeffrey’s stained glass windows are still preserved. Ms. Nowell uses her extensive storytelling experience to portray Hester Jeffrey at events throughout Rochester and the Western New York region. She has served as president of the Blackstorytelling League of Rochester, which is dedicated to improving the well-being of African American people through the tradition of storytelling.


Micjelle Schenandoah

Michelle Schenandoah

An inspirational writer, speaker, and thought leader, Michelle Schenandoah is a member of the Oneida Indian Nation Wolf Clan of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy. Ms. Shenandoah works for community development and leadership for Indigenous women through countless advocacy efforts and as founder of Rematriation Magazine. She also has an extensive background in law and business development, with a JD and LL.M. in Taxation from New York Law School.


Janine Waller

As Chief of Interpretation, Education, and Outreach for the Women’s Rights and Harriet Tubman National Historical Parks, Janine Waller keeps suffrage history alive. She has spent her career sharing America’s stories through her work in the National Park Service.


gold line

Discovering New York Suffrage Stories | Film Credits

Produced by

Lynne Bader

Edited by

Chris Bové

Written by

John Grant

Lynne Bader

Narrated by

Ashley McKay Fowler

Cinematography by

Jim Zinkowski

Sound by

Tami Coleman

Bailey Critoph

Kristin Turo

Mix and Sound Design

Shaun M. Mullins

Propellerhead Media

Production Manager

Tami Coleman

Production Coordinator

Sufana Wajed

Engineer in Charge

Tom Vogel

Story and Archival Research

Anna Musun-Miller

Rachel Kahn-Taylor

Title Design

Eileen Elibol

Promotion

Heather Hare

Web Design

Christy Anne May

Nathen Schneekloth

Foundation Development

Lori Bannister

Education and Outreach

Beth Fronckowiak

Kayla Sears

Project Advisors

Susan Goodier, Ph.D.

Sally Roesch Wagner, Pd.D.

Lillian Williams, Ph.D.

Archives provided by

Alamy

Associated Press

Boston Athenaeum

Boston Public Library

Buffalo History Museum

Cornell University

The Gage Foundation

Getty Images

The Jones Library, Inc., Amherst, MA

Lewis & Clark Digital Collections

Library of Congress

Library of Virginia

Massachusetts Historical Society

Metropolitan Museum of Art – Gift of William E. Dodge & Lila Acheson Wallace

Missouri Historical Society

National Archives

National Association for the Advancement of Colored People

National Susan B. Anthony Museum & House, Rochester, NY

New York Public Library

New York Times

Oberlin College Archives

Oberlin Heritage Center

Rhode Island Historical Society

Rochester Public Library

Rochester Museum & Science Center

Schlesinger Library, Radcliffe Institute, Harvard University

Smithsonian National Museum of African American History and Culture

Syracuse University Library

Tennessee State Library & Archives

University of California

University of Michigan

University of Rochester Library

University of Toronto

Special Thanks

Caleb Abrams

Bear Fox

A.M.E. Zion Church, Rochester, NY

Fayetteville Cemetery

Forest Lawn Cemetery

Michigan Street Baptist Church

Lillie Wiley-Upshaw

Oneida County History Center

Seneca Art & Culture Center at Ganondagan

Women’s Rights National Historical Park

Executive in Charge of Production

David C. Rotterman

Executive Producer

John Grant

“Discovering New York Suffrage Stories” is a Production of Buffalo Toronto Public Media who is solely responsible for its content.

© 2020 Western New York Public Broadcasting Association

Lynne Bader poses in front of a Matilda Joslyn Gage banner
Producer Lynne Bader at the Onondaga Historical Society
Discovering New York Suffrage Stories
WNED PBS crew shoots at the Mary Talbert historic marker
Cinematographer Jim Zinkowski at historical marker for Mary Talbert
Discovering New York Suffrage Stories
WNED PBS crew
Cinematographer Jim Zinkowski and Sound Recordist Kristin Turo
Discovering New York Suffrage Stories
Matilda Joslyn Gage house
The Matilda Joslyn Gage Home allows visitors to explore the house where this co-leader of the early women`s rights movement lived and worked for 44 years.
Discovering New York Suffrage Stories
on-camera interview with Mary Craig
Mary Craig is interviewed by Lynne Bader
Discovering New York Suffrage Stories
Melissa  Almeyda interview
Melissa Almeyda sits down for an interview at the Matilda Joslyn Gage Foundation
Discovering New York Suffrage Stories
view of the Onondaga Historical Society
Shooting at the Onondaga Historical Society
Discovering New York Suffrage Stories
Susan Goodier readies for her on camera interview
Cinematographer Jim Zinkowski sets up for Susan Goodier's interview
Discovering New York Suffrage Stories
Sally Roesch Wagner stands in front of  Matilda Joslyn Gage's grave
Program consultant Sally Roesch Wagner
Discovering New York Suffrage Stories
gold line

Major support for Discovering New York Suffrage Stories was provided by The National Endowment for the Humanities: Exploring the Human Endeavor, by the Susan Howarth Foundation, and KeyBank in partnership with First Niagara Foundation. With additional funding from the Fred L. Emerson Foundation and Humanities New York.